Home / News

Globe editorial: The risky bet of prediction markets

A laptop screen displays trades on the Kalshi website on April 16 in Portland, Ore. Monthly trading volume on the two largest global prediction markets platforms, Kalshi and Polymarket, has skyrocketed.Jenny Kane/The Canadian Press Prediction markets let people bet on the outcome

A laptop screen displays trades on the Kalshi website on April 16 in Portland, Ore. Monthly trading volume on the two largest global prediction markets platforms, Kalshi and Polymarket, has skyrocketed.Jenny Kane/The Canadian Press Prediction markets let people bet on the outcome of real-world events based on a yes-or-no question. Will the Bank of Canada raise interest rates? Will the Dodgers win the World Series again? For the right answer, each contract pays $1; losers get nothing. Participants buy and sell contracts at a price that reflects the odds the market has assigned to a particular event. Canada has opened the door a crack to such markets. We’d wager that the door has already been opened too far. For the trading platforms collecting transaction fees, it can be a lucrative business. The popularity of prediction markets has exploded since 2025, especially among young men. Monthly trading volume on the two largest global platforms, Kalshi and Polymarket, went from less than US$5-billion last September tonearly US$53-billion in July. Betting in prediction markets right now is largely unregulated. Governments around the world are grappling with the question of whether to treat it as gambling or something that belongs in financial markets – or to allow it at all. Prediction markets’ push into U.S. stocks raises regulatory alarm bells In typical fashion, Canada has so far followed the U.S. in choosing the financial markets route but stopped short of allowing everything that U.S. authorities have greenlit. Canadians, for now, can legally bet only on contracts linked to economic indicators, financial markets and climate trends through authorized investing platforms. That excludes contracts tied to popular categories such as sports, politics and entertainment, which the U.S. largely allows. Contracts in Canada must be also linked to events that are at least 30 days in the future, limiting short-term betting. Predictably, there is a push to expand prediction markets. Wealthsimple, one of only two financial firms permitted to offer prediction markets so far, has argued that other types of contracts, such as those related to sports, the biggest driver of bets, should also be regulated as financial instruments. Canada should not heed such calls. There is little evidence that event contracts serve any kind of real-world purpose, unlike financial instruments such as stocks and bonds. But there are growing signs of harm from online wagering. Some argue that prediction markets herald financial innovation. For example, they could serve as a sort of insurance against everyday financial risks. Wealthsimple posits the example of an ice cream vendor, facing the risk of slim sales in a cold summer. To offset that possible hit, goes the argument, they could buy event contracts that pay out in the event of bad weather. In practice, it would take quite the sophisticated ice cream shop to know how many contracts to buy and at what price. That notion melts under scrutiny. Ditto for the claim that prediction markets are a useful forecasting tool. Even in the politics category, where they have a good track record of accurately forecasting the outcome of U.S. presidential elections,only about 1 per centof politics-related event contracts have liquid enough markets for the odds they produce to be considered at all reliable. Opinion: Put plainly, prediction markets are not for you What we do know is that people overwhelmingly use event contracts for gambling. And the risks of online gambling are becoming plain for everyone to see. A recent Canadian study, for example, found that emergency-room visits for gambling-related disorders nearly doubled since Ontario allowed online gambling on private platforms in 2022, with boys and men under the age of 30 accounting for the biggest increase. Pervasive online gambling ads have helped turn online wagering and sports betting into a financial snare for young adults already contending with soaring living costs, high housing prices and the easy-spending traps of social media. Adding sports and other popular categories to Canada’s prediction markets is likely to dramatically broaden their appeal, turning them into yet another domestic venue for betting on the Internet. The correct answer to who should supervise additional types of prediction markets in this country – financial authorities or gambling regulators – is neither. Unless prediction markets evolve into something that shows clear financial utility, securities regulators should refrain from opening the door wider. And Canada should certainly not allow prediction markets under its gambling regime – not until it has restricted gambling and sports-betting ads and found ways to reduce the risk of underage betting and addiction. To do otherwise would be a reckless gamble.