Home / News

Appeals Court Rules Against Kalshi, Dealing Blow to Prediction Market Model

• The U.S. Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled Sept. 25 that Kalshi's event contracts violate state gambling laws in Ohio and Tennessee. • The court explicitly rejected Kalshi's argument that its contracts are federally-regulated "swaps" under the sole jurisdiction of the CFTC. • The ruling represents a victory for state gambling regulators and traditional interests like horse racing, which compete with prediction markets. • The legal conflict, with split rulings in other circuits, increases pressure for a potential U.S. Supreme Court review.

In a significant legal setback for the burgeoning prediction market industry, the United States Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals has ruled that the platform Kalshi is operating in violation of state gambling laws. The September 25 opinion, authored by Judge Julie Smith Gibbons, deals a direct blow to Kalshi’s core legal argument and strengthens the hand of state regulators and established gambling interests, including horse racing. The court’s decision addresses consolidated cases from Ohio and Tennessee, where authorities challenged Kalshi’s model of allowing users to place financial contracts on the outcomes of sporting events. Central to the litigation was Kalshi’s assertion that these contracts constitute “swaps,” sophisticated financial derivatives that fall under the exclusive regulatory purview of the federal Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC). The three-judge panel categorically rejected this defense. “We hold that Kalshi has not shown that its sports-event contracts satisfy the statutory definition of a ‘swap’ so as to fall within the scope of the CFTC’s ‘exclusive jurisdiction,’” the opinion stated. The court further held that even if the contracts were swaps, federal law does not preempt the states’ authority to enforce their own gambling statutes. This ruling carries substantial implications beyond the two states directly involved. The Sixth Circuit’s jurisdiction includes Kentucky and Michigan, potentially affecting Kalshi’s operations there. More broadly, the decision creates a stark circuit split—a key catalyst for Supreme Court review. Kalshi previously lost a similar case in the Ninth Circuit but prevailed in the Third Circuit, setting up conflicting national precedents. This judicial fragmentation underscores the unresolved tension between innovative fintech platforms and traditional gambling regulation. The appellate court’s opinion underscores a growing legal and political confrontation over the future of event-based trading. As noted in the ruling, while the specific cases did not involve horse racing, platforms like Kalshi “compete nationally with horse racing for gambling dollars,” framing the dispute as a battle for market share. The path forward now points toward higher judicial authority. With a clear division among federal appeals courts, industry observers increasingly believe the U.S. Supreme Court will be compelled to resolve the fundamental question of whether prediction markets are gambling or financial instruments, a decision that will define the regulatory landscape for years to come.